Most sensible people treat a beach holiday as an opportunity to relax on the beach – i.e. *a* beach, singular. One beach, max relaxation.
But, since the Eagles basically wrote the song “Learn To Be Still” for me without knowing it, it almost goes without saying that this is not how I do a beach vacation. I can’t sit for more than a couple hours in the sand before I get the itch to go exploring. I have to walk the entire length of the beach at least once. And if there are several beaches, then I’ve got to see a bunch of them.
I really outdid myself on Magnetic Island, though. I managed to see (and step foot on almost) ALL THE BEACHES. Well, at least all the ones accessible on foot, which is just about the entire east coast. There are two lengthy walking tracks that hit all the beaches (from south to north):
- Picnic Bay to Alma Bay: A walking path along the main road leading to Picnic Bay, Nelly Bay (where the ferry terminal is), Geoffrey Bay, Alma Bay
- The Forts to Horseshoe Bay: A wooded track leading to Arthur Bay, Florence Bay, Radical Bay, Balding Bay, Horseshoe Bay
Now, which beaches should you visit? Take a look at them and decide!
Magnetic Island Beaches
Picnic Bay has a jetty, a protected swimming area, and – not surprisingly – some nice picnic areas. Beyond that, it’s not one of the prettier beaches. But from there, you can walk up to a lookout point that yields 360-degree views of Magnetic Island and Townsville in the distance. It’s worth doing, in my opinion.
Nelly Bay is where the ferry terminal is located, but there’s a large stretch of quiet, uninterrupted beach just south of it. Aside from the backpackers at the Base hostel on the south end, you’re not likely to run into many folks here.
Geoffrey Bay is great for taking long walks at low tide. The north end of the beach has some nice tidal flats at this time, with the same rippled texture that Cape Cod’s bay beaches are blessed with. As an added bonus, Geoffrey Bay is in the village of Arcadia, which makes for some fun wandering with its shops and cafes.
Alma Bay is a small cove close to Geoffrey’s. It’s beautiful, but can be crowded since there’s a Surf Lifesaving Club situated there. Alma’s also located in Arcadia, right across from where the weekly market is held.
Arthur Bay is the first beach you reach on the track from The Forts bus stop and entails a walk through swampy mangroves. You can either ford the creek or walk the long way around it. The latter option will take you to a bunch of boulders and a little pond you can wade through to get to the beach. I think this is the best part of Arthur Bay; the beach itself is not the best.
Florence Bay is a local favorite, and it’s easy to see why. A smooth sand beach backed with trees makes it one of the few beaches on Magnetic Island where you can escape the sun and lay in the shade.
Radical Bay is one of the best beaches on Maggie. I got a very Robinson Crusoe feel when I wandered around here, thanks to the tropical flora and rocky cliffs surrounding it. It’s very similar to Balding Bay, albeit slightly bigger. This is the one beach I really wish I’d had more time on.
Balding Bay is tied with Radical Bay for Best Beach on Magnetic Island. It’s the only beach that’s not accessible by vehicle, so you really have to earn its magic. Let me tell you: IT IS WORTH IT. It’s a small beach, but loaded with boulders and nice smooth sand. One thing it doesn’t have? Many (if any) other people, because getting there entails a steep uphill climb from either Horseshoe Bay or Radical Bay. I spent Christmas afternoon here and it was fabulous and peaceful.
I stayed at Bungalow Bay YHA at Horseshoe Bay, which has a woodsy walking track leading to several beaches en route to The Forts. I think it’s the best beach to base yourself at, simply because you’ll be in close proximity to the two prettiest beaches on Maggie: Balding Bay and Radical Bay (mentioned above).
If you’re into water sports, Horseshoe Bay is where it’s at. You can hire boats, ride jetskis, and go on tube rides at this beach. There’s also a sheltered pool here, providing protection from stingers while you swim. Sure, you could take the risk and swim at any beach – but as a solo traveler on a budget, about the last thing I wanted was to pass out from a sting without anyone to take care of me and have to be airlifted to the nearest ER on the mainland. Can you say life-ruiner?
Surprisingly, the most popular activity at Horseshoe Bay is horseback riding! You can ride a horse down the beach at sunset if you fancy. I still have mild PTSD from the time I rode a horse in Italy and it wanted to drown me and my camera while fording a river, so I passed on it this time.
So which is the best beach on Magnetic Island?
My vote’s for Balding Bay and Radical Bay as the most beautiful beaches on Magnetic Island. However, if you’re looking to swim, only two beaches have a swimming area that’s protected from stingers; the better of the two is Horseshoe Bay.
Therefore, I recommend basing yourself at Horseshoe Bay. If you want to swim, hang out at the beach there. When you want to explore or lay out on smooth golden sand, head up the walking path from the end of the beach and take the trail to either Balding Bay or Radical Bay – you’ll reach either one in about a half hour.